To my inexperienced eye im finding it difficult to get to grips with both, the subject matter if really nice..........i love oldy worldy!
The colour image has in my eyes more depth and impact which I think is lost in the B/W version.
I think the bright area in the background by the tree draws the eye away from the cart.
I like the Idea which I guess was difficult with the shade and light and would like to see a non HDR version
Oh by the way today I lost my reading glasses so therse are probably superb