Which one of these is which?

Ian · #1 12-10-10

These are all taken with Ricoh cameras (one with a Ricoh CX4 compact and the other two with a Ricoh GXR - one fitted with the A12 APS-C sensor 33mm macro lens camera module, and one with a P10 compact sensor super zoom camera module:

Image 1

Image 2

Image 3

So which is which?

Ian

Ian · #2 13-10-10

There is actually a big clue as to which is the larger sensor camera

Ian

mike_j · #3 13-10-10

Going by DoF I would guess the first is the big sensor camera and the last is the compact. All very good though.

Ian · #4 13-10-10

Here are 100& crops (1:1 pixels) of each of the images originally shown in this thread:

Image a

Image b

Image c

Now which is which?

Ian

Graham_of_Rainham · #5 13-10-10

I'm going to "suggest":

Image a was taken with the GXR with the A12 50mm Macro

Image b with the GXR and the P10 28-300

Image c from the CX4

The shot has "a good range of shadow detail as well as bright highlights, as well as a range of colour and details" making it ideal for comparison of the three cameras.

Ian · #6 14-10-10

Of the three, one is agreeably the worst and this is because it's from an an-adjusted raw file:

Unadjusted

Here is a version I have adjusted in Lightroom 3.2.

Ian

jrtrent · #7 12-10-12

I realize this thread is old, but what was the answer? Which is which?

Ian · #8 12-10-12

Aha! Well spotted - I will dig out the originals and report back later today!

Ian

Patrick · #9 13-10-12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ian

Aha! Well spotted - I will dig out the originals and report back later today!

Ian

Also interesting to know what happened to the camera, not seen anyone using one anywhere.

Patrick